COS 597A, Fall 2008 - Problem Set 3

Due at 5:00pm, Friday  October 17, 2008
You may submit electronically or by hardcopy: bring your hardcopy submission to my office or put it in my mailbox in the CS mailroom on the 2nd floor.

Collaboration Policy

You may discuss problems with other students in the class. However, each student must write up his or her own solution to each problem independently. That is, while you may formulate the solutions to problems in collaboration with classmates, you must be able to articulate the solutions on your own.

Late Penalties


Problem 1.  (left as an exercise in class 10/6/08)
Consider again Board Example 4 for the relational calculus (see slides posted for 10/1):

students: (SS#, name, PUaddr, homeAddr, classYr)
employees: (SS#, name, addr, startYr)
assignment: (position, division, SS#, managerSS$ )
division foreign key referencing PUdivision
SS# 
foreign key referencing employees
managerSS#  foreign key referencing employees
study: (SS#, academic_dept., adviser)
SS# foreign key referencing students
PUdivision: (division_name, address, director)

The problem was to express the query  "Find academic departments that have students working in all divisions" in the relational calculus.
Our board solution was:

{ T | M ε study ( T[academic_dept]=M[academic_dept] )
          D ε PUdivision  A ε assignment M2 ε study   (
                         A[division]= D[division_name] A[SS#]=M2[SS#]
              M2[academic_dept] = T[academic_dept]  )

Question:  If PUdivision is empty, what is the result of this relational calculus query?  Be precise.


Problem 2.
In slide # 13 of  the SQL presentation (posted for 10/6/08), we considered the SQL query "Find names of all branches with accts of cust. who live in Rome":
SELECT A.bname
FROM Acct A
WHERE A.acctn IN (SELECT D.acctn
    FROM Owner D, Cust C
    WHERE D.name = C.name AND C.city=‘Rome’)
Call the result of this query Result_in_Rome.  

Now consider query:
SELECT A.bname
FROM Acct A
WHERE A.acctn NOT IN (SELECT D.acctn
    FROM Owner D, Cust C
    WHERE D.name = C.name AND C.city=‘Rome’)
Call the result of this query Result_not_in_Rome.

Is Result_not_in_Rome πbname(A ) - Result_in_Rome ?   Justify your answer.

Problem 3.
Consider again the SQL example in slide #28 of the SQL presentation (posted for 10/6/08).   The English description of the query that we came up with in class on 10/8  is wrong.  See the correction slides (pdf). What is the correct English description of  what the query produces? 

Problem 4.
The Department of Computer Science maintains a database of technical reports using the software MySQL. Normally, this is accessed from the department's technical reports server. However, the technical staff have prepared a SQL Web interface so that you may play with a real database (or rather a snapshot of it). This database is somewhat different from the examples we have been using in that it has much more text and little numerical data. There are only two tables, defined as:
TABLE main (
  id varchar(10),
  entry date,
  org varchar(75),
  language varchar(20),
  title tinytext,
  date varchar(30),
  pages varchar(15),
  abstract text,
  ps enum('Y','N'),
  pdf enum('Y','N'),
  PRIMARY KEY (id),
  UNIQUE id (id)
);


TABLE authors (
  id char(10),
  author char(50),
  ord tinyint(3) unsigned
);
The different types are extensions of the basic types and are described in the Language Reference linked from the SQL Web interface. However, all you really need to know is that tinyint(3) unsigned is a type of integer, date is a specific format of string that allows for meaningful comparison of dates,  and that varchar, char, tinytext and text are all types of strings so that one can use the SQL operator "LIKE".  Note that attribute entry records the date the technical report (TR)  was entered in the database and attribute date records when the writing of the TR was completed.  

Part 0 (warm-up, don't turn in) To get an understanding of what the entries in main and authors look like, go to the SQL Web interface and enter and submit these four SQL queries, one at a time:

select *
from main M
where M.date='April 2006'

select M.entry, M.date
from main M
where M.entry < '1994-05-01'
select *
from authors A
where A.id='TR-595-99'
select *
from authors A
where A.author LIKE 'Walker%'
Part 1. Write and submit SQL queries to find the following. Hand in a print-out of the results of each query.  Note that for long queries,  the print-out of the SQL Web interface page with the  result will cut off the query, so you need to type it on a separate page.

Query a: Find the names of all authors of TR's dated in the summer of 2002 (June, July and August).

Query b: Find the ids, titles, and dates of the TRs with the word "security" in their abstracts.

Query c: Find the names of all co-authors of Professor Appel in technical reports dated sometime in 2001.

Query d: For those authors who have published more than 1 TR in 2004, find their names and the number of TRs they published in 2004.

Query e:  Find the entry date(s) when the most TRs were entered and the number of TRs entered on that entry date. "Entry date" refers to the entry attribute, not the date attribute.

Part 2. Why do you think the database was organized the way it was: two tables with the data recorded as indicated in the table definitions? Would you organize it differently? Be sure to consider the use of this database as represented by the technical report server.


Problem 5.
One database system to which you have access is the Princeton University Instructional Oracle Facility. Go to the Princeton University Instructional Oracle Facility Web site and follow the directions to establish an account. Then go to the Instructional Oracle SQL Editor. You will use the Web interface provided there to define tables and insert and delete values.

Important: 
The local copies of  Oracle 8 documentation linked at the bottom of the  Princeton University Instructional Oracle Facility Web site no lonter exist.  Furthermore, the current version being run by the facility is Oracle 9.2   Documentation can be obtained from Oracle:  Oracle9i SQL Reference: Table of Contents.  To turn in your work, use the browser print command to print your sequence of SQL commands and the results. Note that the full sequence of commands must be executed at one time (one transaction) in the editor window to appear as a sequence in the bottom frame, where the results also appear. Also, you must have the bottom frame selected to print both the command sequence and the results.  If you wish to submit your work by email, cut and paste the contents of the bottom frame to a text file and email that.   Be sure to save your tables in your Oracle database until your work  has been graded.

For this problem we will use the following database for a consulting firm:

Underlined attributes constitute the primary key for a relation -- our usual convention.

Part 1 Define tables corresponding to the 4 relations in your Oracle database. Include definitions of PRIMARY KEY constraints and FOREIGN KEY constraints.

Part 2 Add two consultants with at least two clients each and two consultants with no clients; at least one consultant must have a supervisor for each client with which he/she is paired. Of course, you can use minimalist names so that you don't need to do a lot of typing.

Part 3  Show that the Oracle facility enforces FOREIGN KEY constraints by executing a sequence of inserts and deletes for two of the relations (your choice of which) to illustrate enforcement. Show (i) that a tuple cannot be deleted in the referenced table if the primary key value of that tuple is present as the foreign key value of a tuple in the referencing table, (ii) that the primary key value of a tuple cannot be changed in the referenced table if that primary key  value is present as the foreign key value of a tuple in the referencing table, and (iii) that a tuple cannot be added in the referencing table if the foreign key value in that tuple is not present as a primary key value in a tuple of the referenced table.

WARNING: You must follow each INSERT or DELETE or UPDATE command with a COMMIT command on a separate line for the ORACLE database system to permanently store or delete the values. For example:

        insert into works (name, c_name, fee_rate) values ('smith', 'jones', 100);
        commit;
See Item 3 under Guidelines on Specifying SQL Commands To SQL Editor in the SQL Editor Tutorial.




NOTE:  If you have a Computer Science Department account, then you also have access to a MySQL database server that can be used for course or research projects or for further exploration of database systems.   See CS Guide: Database.  If you have a CS account,  you can get a MySQL account by filling out the form Database Setup on CS Guide list of Request Forms.  WARNING:  CS Guide pages are restricted to local (i.e. cs.princeton.edu) access.  If you do not have a CS account but would like to work with the MySQL database server, please email Professor LaPaugh.